Jeremy Shockey
Normally i'm all for the problem child that is a great player. However in Shockey's case, he isn't necessarily great, and his team made a Super Bowl run after his injury. I know he's more talented than Boss, but his ego weighed down Eli. We have a disciplined team, i'd rather take a chance on a thug like Pacman Jones than a locker room enemy like Shockey who will down his coaches and teamates. At least Pacman vents his frustrations in strip clubs.