The Pete Carmichael Problem

SWJJ said
The the reddit guy MUST be lying because that play starts at the 41, and he says Carr takes a sack, but on the next slide he says "very next play" but the line of scrimmage is the 47, so it could not have been the next play or he could not have been sacked.

just to clear this up...

(12:45) L.Young reported in as eligible. D.Carr sacked at NO 38 for -3 yards (S.Barrett).PENALTY on TB-S.Barrett, Face Mask, 15 yards, enforced at NO 41 - No Play.

Was a sack... but it wasn't the very next play cause, the next play was when Kamara ran backwards out of bounds. And that's more on Carmichael for the design of going east to west too much this game instead of north and south.

(12:26) (Shotgun) D.Carr pass short middle to A.Kamara pushed ob at 50 for -6 yards (A.Winfield).

So no don't trust the reddit user 100%. But if yall didn't see Carr holding the ball staring down receivers instead of taking what was available all game long, I can't help you.

Carr should not have played with his Arm out of sorts without a full week of getting used to where it was at.

and get this straight as well as my point of view. people just like to gloss over the details. the Reddit post says this "Carmichael isn't completely to blame. Carr has to make the easy throws. A breakdown from some misses this last game"

some serious Gloss