Finishing 12-5 would mean that we figured it out and we finally have the team we expected coming into this season.
Finishing 11-6 would mean that we figured it out and it's "okay" to get our hopes up a little for at least a "any given Sunday" playoff run.
Finishing 10-7 would mean we're better than we were, but still need some work. Probably good enough for a playoff appearance.
Finishing 9-8 would mean we are who we are, and not much hope. Possible playoff appearance with some help.
Finishing 8-9 or worse would mean we just aren't a good team, with plenty of ammo for the blame-game. Pick your narrative, pick your villains.