The problem with arguing with people about this topic is there is probably nothing Carr can do at this point to change their mind. Good or bad. Hes either terrible or great from week to week and the truth is he’s somewhere in between. He’s an average qb.
Same as Winston, but does that justify sticking with him or you try something different. He’s thrown an INT in every game the last few games, all leading to scoring drives for the opponent or pick sixes.