Derek Carr - Why People Dislike Him (IMO)

It also begs the question, even in the best of circumstances would Derek Carr magically become a great QB and a leader of men?

To me, this is just a another bad decision by personnel folks (Loomis, et al) to placate an incompetent head coach.....

Both can be true....(which was kind of my point all along)....
Best of circumstances? Whatis that? I guarantee that if SP was here we'd be at least 9-4 maybe 10-3 and already have won the division , WITH the same personnel. DC had quite a few moments of being an above-average to very good QB in LV when he had good coaching, heck even when Del Rio was HC he was 3rd in the MVP voting and they went 12-4 and Del Rio is not a great coach