Derek Carr - Why People Dislike Him (IMO)

Jesse Custer said
New QB and coach. I've seen what Payton has done with a Russ who looked totally washed last season and I don't have much faith in anyone outside of Sean being able to make Jameis more serviceable. Frankly, I wouldn't be surprised to see Jameis sign in Denver as a backup just to be with Sean again.

I think a guy like Jason Garrett could get more out of a lot of these QBs as an OC. He coached both Tony Romo and Dak into serviceable QBs. Where he failed was more as a head coach.

jahsoul357 said
You don't need a unicorn coach. Just a coach to build around their strengths, just like every other QB. Honest question, what does "turn them into stars you don't have to worry about" actually means and what would we have to actually worry about?

I don't want to nitpick the coaches both of them have had with you. It reeks of excuse making for mid players and coaches. If they had been a good match, we wouldn't be having this conversation.

For the point you made that I quoted, I mean that you build a system that removes the bad tendencies and amplify their best tendencies and still has the QB looking like their natural selves. Jameis under Payton played like he was on a leash. It took away the things that made him who he is. That was both good and bad, but he certainly didn't look like he was playing with instinct. He looked like he was thinking about not turning the ball over every down and you don't want that. More time may have changed that to some degree, but it was not meant to be.