He really is a great musician. Listen to Everlong's drum part and try to tell me with a straight face he isn't an incredible drummer. Any drummer will tell you how good he is. Pretty good guitarist as well for that not being his primary instrument. Certianly better than ol sloppy strumming He Who Shall Not Be Named. Whether or not you like Foo Fighters it's kinda hard to deny he's a highly regarded musician by many, some also very highly regarded, musicians. And I've also heard that Foo Fighters put on a hell of a show.