What to expect moving forward

That is truly pathetic. Its gonna go from bad to toxic w/ this fanbase. Once you start winning, you can't ever go back. Just ask LSU fans.
Except... this is the NFL, and everybody goes back. Look at the Patriots - they seemed unconquerable for twenty years in a row, and now they look like the worst-team-on-Tecmo-Bowl Patriots. Their fans don't seem to be abandoning the team, and they have really good reasons to do so (emerging powers in their division, a failed first-round QB, little to be optimistic about on either side of the ball, not a free agent destination).

College is structured differently, with different means of acquiring/retaining talent, and even the pipeline guarantees are vastly different. Future NFL players are subject to a draft.