Derek Carr was a top 10 QB in 2023

Saint Spud said

I’m not putting Carr ahead of the following QBs when healthy:

Mahomes, Jackson, Burrow, Allen, Stroud, Lawrence, Stafford, Herbert, Purdy, Goff, Rodgers, Dak, Love, Hurts, Cousins.

He’s in a group with Tua, Mayfield, Geno Smith, etc who can look really good when stuff around them is perfect.

Click to expand...

Respectfully, you’re reaching. Stats don’t lie but I’ll take a shot at arguing subjectively.

Lawrence is two years away from competing for a starting job. Rodgers is on the decline. Dak is a choke artist. Goff is a choke artist. Stafford is brittle. Love is a choke artist. Hurts is a choke artist. Cousins is a choke artist. Jackson is a choke artist. Tua is a choke artist. Mayfield, you guessed it, a choke artist.

Your list of players you place above and on par with Carr is trash. Respectfully.