TenTwo, I stayed with you though I disagreed--until your reply post.
I would suggest that Carr's numbers in 2023 were inflated by the Saints playing a historically weak schedule and that there is merit to Matt Moscona's argument that Derek Carr is the Emperor of Empty Yards.
I would also suggest that most of the quarterbacks you assailed as "choke artists" will be ranked higher in the quarterback rankings we will see before the 2024 season. And the quarterbacks you think little of have actually played in big games unlike Derek Carr, who in 10 seasons has had only three winning seasons (including the Saints' 2023 season) and has played in only one playoff game.