Derek Carr was a top 10 QB in 2023

Deuuuuce said

Quarterbacks should be judged by wins and losses.

Click to expand...

Strongly disagree. Coaches should be measured by wins and losses. What influence does the QB have on the defense? The QB should be judged on his ability to operate an offense. How well he plays the position. Accuracy, arm strength, progressions, footwork, anticipation, reading defenses.

Wins and losses is just the lazy way fans like to generalize things. Blame it all on the QB. But the reality of how the position is valued is based on what I’m talking about. You want to judge a QB on his ability to win the game down a score with 2 minutes to play? Yeah, that’s valid. But just a blanket Ws vs Ls that just tells me he was on a good team. With good players around him and a good coaching staff who put the QB in a position to succeed.

It’s this thought process I use to argue that Drew Brees was the greatest QB of all time.