Derek Carr was a top 10 QB in 2023

TenTwo said

“Most metrics”

Show them to us. Otherwise it’s just sounds like you made something up.

And when you cherry pick which games to use, you just water down your stance. And when you talk about the last 4 games, as if that’s some subset of data we should view as an anomaly…why? Were those not the most important games? I would argue that if we’re cherry picking to make a point, those games hold more value in both terms of ability to operate under pressure and forecasting future results.

GG

Click to expand...

@Rouxble already told you that he was 17th in DVOA

He was 17th in EPA/Play
He was 17th in Adj. EPA/Play
He was 17th in ESPN QBR (which is basically EPA adjusted for situations)
I want to say he was 14th in DYAR (but I can't remember where I saw that).

And how am I cherry picking? I just gave you where where he stood the first 13 games of the season and then showed you the last 4, which confirms my stance. We are only having this conversation because the last 4 games of the season practically doubled his TDs, added 1k yards, shot up his completion percentage, and his passer rating. The end.

I'm not saying that this is not something that we can't build on but 4 games shouldn't erase 13, although history shows that it do (for some).