Derek Carr was a top 10 QB in 2023

Deuuuuce said

Everyone should get blame. Over the course of an entire game there are always particular plays that stand out that might just go down in the box score as an incomplete pass for instance. But if that incomplete pass is a simple throw that should have been a touchdown its worth way more than just 0-1. The Qb can complete 80 percent of his passes, but if he has 1 or 2 really bad incompletions that would have iced the game, he deserves blame.

Click to expand...

And that's all that I'm saying. I can't just make wins and losses about a QB when the reality is it can be so many things. Like you mentioned, we have seen many games where the offense didn't play the best but made a run to take the lead for the defense fail on the final drive. I can't say "that's the QB." While he might not have played the best all game, he put them in position to win. I think we are agreeing with each other in different ways..haha.