Derek Carr was a top 10 QB in 2023

DSnfla said
Mahomes was good his receivers couldn't catch or line up right

Funny that nobody blamed the receivers when Alex Smith was having the same issues with his receivers. Mahomes drop rate this season is about the average for Alex Smith from 2013-2016, and that's with Smith having less "bad throws." LOL. But again, another topic for another day.

SweetT said
Mahomes had a down year due to his own standards. He was good enough to get his team to the Super Bowl. It’s the goal of every team and QB. He is playing for the ultimate prize and we are here arguing if DC4 is a top 10 QB…….SMDH
His worst season is a career year for most QBs. Dude is a 2 time champion and people are already talking about him being the GOAT if he wins this Super Bowl. His name should be not mentioned at all in this thread bc he has done what every other QB desires to do.

Not a knock but sometimes, you gotta know who is driving and who is along for the ride.

*those 2000 Ravens...SMH. Allow 2TDs the entire playoffs....TWO*

And I don't adhere to that GOAT talk. It would interested to see what he does without Big Red and Kelce. I'll let his career finish out before I place him anywhere.