Derek Carr was a top 10 QB in 2023

TenTwo said

Respectfully, you’re reaching. Stats don’t lie but I’ll take a shot at arguing subjectively.

Lawrence is two years away from competing for a starting job. Rodgers is on the decline. Dak is a choke artist. Goff is a choke artist. Stafford is brittle. Love is a choke artist. Hurts is a choke artist. Cousins is a choke artist. Jackson is a choke artist. Tua is a choke artist. Mayfield, you guessed it, a choke artist.

Your list of players you place above and on par with Carr is trash. Respectfully.

Click to expand...

The fact you can list that group of players as "trash" while hyping up Derek fricking Carr is the definition of irony.

Carr is a career loser, who put up average stats on a historically easy schedule. He's never won anything of note and our own players don't seem to like the guy. He was getting booed in the Dome, not even halfway thru his first season here. And rightfully so.

If we couldn't win the South this year with Carr, we'll never win anything with him. This was as easy as the division and schedule are ever going to be and we blew it with him leading the way.