Because he has been more right this season about our team than most of the "trusted" media. I look at it as part of 2 factions:
-You have the insider group that will moreso give things from the "organization" viewpoint.
-You have the group that looks at things from a fan's perspective, which is heavy opinion based.
The thing about this is the latter group is willing to be more honest, quicker than the prior. So for a lot of what was going on during the season, Matt M. was more right than wrong, especially when compared to the more "legitimate" group. Does he give his hot takes? Yep, but so does the other group ("Derek Carr is the perfect fit for Pete Carmichael's offense" 🫢). I don't dismiss his takes, like I don't others, unless it can factually be disputed. Because at the end of the day, we all have opinions about this team.