You make a compelling argument about Chicago, similar to Zach Wilson going to the jets. Zach Wilson is still a wildly over drafted QB going to a bad team. This doesn't how ever, promise sucess at another team.
Ill agree. NYJ would be the clear 2nd QB graveyard in the NFL. Their single season yardage leader is Joe Namath. In 1967. In a 14 games schedule. But I dont think Wilson wouldve been worth his draft pick on any of the other 31 teams though. He just doesnt have it. Whether you play outdoors up north, or in a dome - a roof cant overcome lack of talent. It was a reach by the Jets, and it turned out exactly like youd expect.
No one was comparing Wilson to Brady or Brees or Manning though. People compare Williams to Mahomes. And he was pretty clearly better than Mahomes in college. "Generational" gets tossed around with him. Playing 9 games in a dome doesnt make you a good qb, but it does remove a boatload of factors - which is buoyed by Brees numbers. And just about any other QBs numbers playing indoors vs outdoors.
You may think Daniels or Maye should be the 1st qb off the board, but not taking Williams at 14? I dont know.