Those comments aren't inconsistent. He does have a little bit of upside, but even his best isn't above mid-level NFL starter and not good enough to carry a team to make it good on his own.
You're overreacting and failing to comprehend as usual.
Youre talking about a guy who has been in the NFL for 10 years, under numerous systems and is still 15 games under .500 as a starter. But we can keep talking about his upside until he is on Medicare.
He hasnt played in a communist system, maybe thatll be the one that works.