Play Haener

I agree with your point. And based on this being their job and what they’ve trained to do you would expect them to be better than fans or reporters but unfortunately that’s often not the case.
Sorry but you nor I really don't know which scouts say what about certain players. Even the info they put out may just be misinformation to shy other teams away from players they like . It's not the scout's job to draft a player where or when. AND it's always more than 1 or 2 scouts evaluation that a coach or GM has to go on when making a decision. Believe me they ARE better than fans or reporters.