Ranking All 16 Projected Starting QBs in the NFC for 2024

tim martin said

i never said he was better. i just said it’s not as laughable as it would have been his super bowl year. Hurts was just not the same player last year and struggled throwing the ball with awesome weapons. i have 2 die hard eagle fans in my family and they both hate him. they think the league has figured him out a little and doesn’t throw it well enough. Carr has had nothing but headaches his whole career with it seems like 100 coaching changes. put him in any great franchise and he makes the playoffs plenty

Click to expand...

While Hurts did not have a 2023 season like his 2022 season, he was still plenty good enough to win enough to get his team into the playoffs. He guided his team to a 10-1 record through the first 11 games, until that team self destructed. Objectively speaking, DC4 (along with our offense), didn’t click until the final 5 games or so. So how does that mean DC4 played better than Hurts? It makes no sense. Plus, you can’t just use hypotheticals, to jump a player in rankings. If you say DC4 would be a top 5/10 QB “IF” he was instantly inserted on a good team, with stability and such, then you have to do that for a lot of other QBs. That is not how that goes. We are all Saints fans and we all want to see DC4 be the best, or one of the best QBs in the entire NFL, but we can not do that, unless his play leads us to success.