Good analysis of Carr
Carr is a perennial "14-16th best QB". His QBR in the last 5 years is 10, 11, 14, 14, and 16th in 2023. Baseball has the "Mendoza Line". Football has the "Dalton Line". It's the QB who is just good enough statistically and can get you to the playoffs intermittently, but can't win a playoff game. It's the QB just above replacement but below what you really want. Arguably, Carr is even below this line as Dalton has a career win record of 86-82-2 with 4 playoff losses to Carr's 72-88 with 1 playoff loss.