Except the last 10 weeks of last season when he was statistically in the top 3 QBs in all of football and arguably the best QB in football the last month. Not opinion, it’s literally his stats and plenty of pieces written out there about it.
Is Carr Brees? Good lord, no. But man that guy takes a beating on this board and most refuse to acknowledge when he plays exceptionally well.
My issue with Carr is he just can’t throw people open or with much anticipation. He has to see the guy open first. Problem is 70% or more of the QBs in the game are like that, the very good or great ones have that skill, that’s part of what makes them great. However, he is definitely serviceable if the rest of your team does its job. He needs a good supporting cast, a clean pocket, and an effective gameplan. But, the fact that some just talk about him like he’s trash shows they have an agenda or just don’t understand the position.