Catholic Church Scandal!

Well, it kind of is, but it kind of isn't. Whether and when Mary did it with Joseph is a superficial detail to the rest of the story. But some folks seem to be so certain that she didn't re: Jesus, so it is a useful topic going back up this thread re: the molester-enablers who have been brainwashing folks with this stuff for 2000 years.
The first Chapter of Luke makes it pretty clear, though, at least being a virgin through Jesus' conception. As far as her perpetual virginity, I agree that it seem tangential. Thomas Aquinas also didn't believe in it. It's one of the few things the Catholic Church rejects from Aquinas' work.