Trying to absolve Carr of what he did is just plain silly. While someone could have chipped Judon doesn't take away the fact that Carr stared at an unblocked Judon and proceeded to throw it directly at the mans face. He panicked like he always does and makes bad decisions with the football. He is an underwhelming player that isnt a good decision maker which is why he wins about 45% of his games and has 0 playoff wins in 12 years.