Since I know nobody on here really looked at any games before he got here, answer me this; when he was a healthy starter here, how many games did he lose for us?
He lost the same number of games that he won for us. Zero.
We won with Winston at QB because Payton kept the reins on him and didn't let him play hero ball.
Winston was a different QB before SP and is a different QB after SP. His play under SP cannot honestly be used to substantiate the position that Winston doesn't make any more bad decisions than any other QB.