What More Must Taysom Hill Do Before He Retires To Be Considered An NFL Hall Of Fame Player?

lilvipa221 said
Absolutely incorrect. Devin Hester broke records and has won plenty of honors as an NFL player. Taysom doesn't have anything Hester has done. Hester is the best returner in NFL history. If Taysom was justifiably the best at something and had a ton of random stats then yes but he doesn't.

Yep. 4 Pro Bowls, 3 All Pros, and an all-decade team selection for Hester. Zero of any of those accolades for Taysom. Their hall-of-fame resumes are not comparable. Taysom's best attribute is his rushing but even then his rushing numbers (never higher than 575 yards in a season) are nowhere near HOF level. He needs to have a lot of rushing games like the 2022 Seahawks game or this year's Browns game to get consideration. He has a total of three 100-yard rushing games in his entire career.

His passing stats aren't going to make anyone outside of this board say he's a hall of famer (11 TDs to 9 INTs, never started a full season as QB1). He's improved as a receiver but his stats there aren't going to catch HOF voters' eyes either (best season 33 catches for 291 yards). He's a good special teams player, has blocked a few kicks and hustles as a gunner, but...hasn't made a pro bowl for special teams either.

If a current Saints player has a shot at the HOF for all-purpose contributions, it's Kamara (ROY, 5 Pro Bowls, way more rushing & receiving yards & TDs than Taysom).