Interesting fact I found that also answers the question
@Artifactual asked.
There isn’t a single player in the Hall of Fame that played after 1950 who doesn’t have at least one Pro Bowl.
So what does Hill need to do? He needs to get that first Pro Bowl for starters, otherwise he would be setting a different kind of record by making the HOF without one.
Edit: There is one, Ken Riley, that made it. However, he had a 1st team AP to his name, and he is fifth all time on the career interception leaderboard.
So Hill needs at least one of a PB or AP, but few players have made it recently without multiple.