Could Rattler be our QB1 after another year or 2 of development? (merged)

Let these two compete. I have little doubt that Carr would win out in training camp next year. I also have little doubt that 1 more season as a backup with a new head coach that's revamping the talent on the team would also best serve Rattler for a 2026 take over as QB1. Will he work out and be a franchise QB? No idea. We've seen plenty of QB's in the last two decades who appeared to be answers after a few games or even a full season just to completely bomb out and be well below mediocre.

But another season as QB2 while the new coach revamps the talent on the offense would help put Rattler in better position to succeed in 2026.