Should Rattler be our starter in 2025? (merged)

No.

Rattler so far looks like nothing more then a career backup. He's slow to recognize the defense, he's slow in anticipating receivers becoming open and he's oblivious to disguises. I can't recall a time when these issues were fixed in a QB at the NFL level to become a quality QB1. Otherwise QB's like Nick Foles and Winston would be hall of famers.