If someone is going to represent my opinions over the years, I would hope he would strive for accuracy, though I suppose I should be pleased if someone remembers reading my posts 15 to 20 years ago.
I have never called for Loomis's head over the last 15 to 20 years. I have repeatedly given Loomis credit for the team's success during the Payton years--for hiring Payton, for signing Brees, for setting aside ego when working with Payton, and for creating an organizational process that allowed Payton to be the architect of the team to be built and acting as the contractor in building the structure Payton wanted to build. I have written many times that Payton was the de facto general manager. It was meant as a compliment to Loomis that he could preside smoothly over an organization where the head coach exercised such power.
I was critical of Loomis with Bountygate--especially if the NFL had earlier warned the Saints and other teams about bounties. I have often been highly critical of the Saints in moving up in the draft and trading away draft picks. My serious criticism of our drafting began with the Davenport selection. I was also highly critical of the 2022 pre-draft trade with Philadelphia. I did believe a serious rebuild should have begun much earlier. I was not admirers of Dennis Allen and Derek Carr. I believe I was strongly opposed to our efforts of trying to sign Deshaun Watson. On many of these issues, my memory is that Underhill endorsed, and at times was in lockstep with, what Loomis was doing. But regarding commentators, to each his own. I concede Underhill spends more time watching film and trying to break down what happened during games than most in the media with the notable exception of Deuce.
Regarding the views of other forum members, I think the spirit of this forum and courtesy suggest that I not discuss their past views and that I allow them to state their opinions. Additionally, I do not keep track of what people wrote on the forum a year ago (though it seems over the years I have myself agreeing with much of what Guillermo has written).