Trent Dilfer won a SuperBowl. You don't need an elite QB to win a championship but it's just way harder to do it without one. I've never been a huge fan of Carr and when we signed him I was not too excited but the amount of vitriol he gets from some portion of our fanbase is also unwarranted and, quite honestly, disgusting to me. The organization has failed since Payton left. That's the truth of the situation, Carr is a part of that failing but not because of himself rather because the organization has failed to understand their own predicament. I think we'll turn it around but unless we catch lightning in a bottle it won't be overnight.