I mean, without hindsight who else are you gonna put in the top 4? tOSU should have been a top 4 team. ND lost to NIU although that obviously was a fluke and very early in the season. Texas wasn't exactly impressive and probably should have lost to ASU. UGA was a top 4 team and should have been based on their season. They didn't play well at all tonight.
No one would have put PSU in the top 4 before this week. So... :shrug:
I can’t honestly say that I followed all the teams who made the playoffs. But I’m guessing that Penn State and Ohio State will be playing for all the marbles. Of the top 4 in the playoffs, only Arizona State put up a real fight.