For anyone who says Carr is just a stat padder and don’t win:

BensonJr said
The Saints will not win the division, make the playoffs or be relevant for at least 5 years+ but Derek Carr is not at the top of the list of problems. The Saints and Panthers are fighting it out for the least talented team in the NFC, we are $50m+ over the salary cap, we have no coach and we are only drafting 10th. These issues are much bigger than Carr.

That said Carr will probably only be ranked 15-20th at his position next year, and sadly that maybe the highest ranked player we have if McCoy and Olave are not healthy.

He's also not the top of our solutions either. He's a waste of time. Rather develop Rattler and keep drafting QBs until we find one.

Hank said
Put Josh Allen, Mahomes, Stafford behind this Saints OL, Zero WRs to throw to, sub par tight ends that cant get separation or YAC, hurt/old Rbs and lets see how many Ws they get. Team sport, team around Carr is hurt or below average.

OK, So this years excuse is OL and WR. Last years was Pete Carmichael. What's next years annual Derek Carr excuse going to be? He never wins but always has an excuse.