Mathieu probably has the lowest chances of the three, but it's definitely true that making the all-decade team is the minimum (and the likely indicator) for making the HOF after retirement. On the PFR HOF monitor, making an all-decade team is worth 25 points, well more than any other accolade (a season MVP is worth 12.5, a 1st team AP selection is 2.5, a Pro Bowl is 1.5, almost everything else is less).