I don't find so much fault in them because it boils down to a missed evaluation on Carr.
For instance, lets say their assessment of Carr is right. Lets say he ends up navigaing Carmichael/Paytons system w/ Gusto. 4000 yards and 30 TD's in year one and we make the playoffs. That restructure that they know is going to take place in a year does, but nobody cares because we're winning. They got it wrong on Carr and getting it wrong shines a very bright flashlight.