Not really this got broken down years ago when he was a Raider. Of the top of my head it was around these high level points:
4,000-4500 yards a season which isn’t bad.
But here is where the problem starts:
- his TD production per year is actually fairly low he averages around 24 TD passes a season. That would have been fine but Herbert and Mahomes were throwing for 10+ more than him.
INTs- last season with the Raiders he had something like 14 in addition to seven lost fumbles or so. In other words almost as many turnovers as TDS.
Another notable was going almost three years (I think it was 2018-2020) with 2 TD games as a maximum. That right nothing about 2 for three seasons it was puzzling.
Then add to this his myriad of issues: lack of vision on the field, hearing phantom steps, fumbling the ball out of the end zone, propensity to throw the ball away with the game in the line (happened). What are you left with and these aren’t even all his flaws.
He’s one of the most fascinating QBs ever because he has almost every physical tool but is lacking in the mental and processing part. I’m convinced he literally does not see the field that well. Or at best struggles with initial reads 2 progressions.
There he never been a QB I can think of outside of Joey Harrington with the Lions who has gotten such leeway. Even then the Lions were smart to pull the plug after 5, took the Raiders almost 10.
Hey maybe he gets it in 2025. Is anyone going to stake a lot on that? I sure wouldn’t.