Should Rattler be our starter in 2025?

Ok so here is my take.
!. Carr is not our answer.
2. we have one more year with him. use that to build the team.
3 . Rattler isn't the answer either. he throws high to often and behind the receivers to often.
4. Rattler knows all the right words to say but look at him after a play that flops. he doesn't hold himself accountable you can see on his face he is more upset at his fellow players. it really bothers me when i see this.
5. rattlers college carrier is not good why should we believe his pro carrier would be.