Should Rattler be our starter in 2025?

You are saying that like he was not part of 10 and 12 win teams and that was with a horrible D. If the 1st 2 games were not a peek into what our offense can be and what DC can be then I don't know what I can tell you
Ryan Fitzpatrick started the 2018 season with 819 yards and 8 tds with 1 interception while he led the bucs to a 2-0 record, one notoriously against us.........then reality set in just like Derek Carr's reality. After those two games Carr went 3-5 and played pedestrian football like he always has for his career.

Just because you have a 2 game stretch against terrible teams it doesn't mean thats how the rest of the season will go or he and the team will play like that to infinity.