I think you kinda always want the new and exciting option. It’s mysterious and you don’t really know how it’ll turn out but it’s fresh and different so you’re on board.
But, there’s times where you just need an old reliable hand to come in and stabilize the team and stop the bleeding. A guy who knows how to fix these issues that have plagued the team for several years.
McCarthy may not set the world on fire but I think at worst he makes the team respectable again and gets us back into contention for the NFC South. At best he could find the freedom to be best version of himself here and have an Andy Reid-like renaissance.
So yeah I’m not against hiring McCarthy.