You completely lost me here. There are some legit criticisms of McCarty, but if you bar is set so high that current Sean Payton who just turned around Denver, developed a young QB, and got them in the playoffs in 2 years isn't good enough for you, I get why you wouldn't want McCarty. And the reason is that your expectations are unreasonably high. So high that not a single coach that could be hired this year would likely ever meet them when a HoF coach isn't good enough for you.