Reid didn’t have a player mutiny nor was his game planning reportedly so abysmal that players started running different plays like McCarthy.
Yes Andy Reid’s last two seasons with the Eagles were bad, but it’s attributed to grief since his son died at training camp.
Reid needed a fresh beginning from a tragedy involving the death of his son. McCarthy just became a bad coach and it showed it Dallas.
Reid is having massive success in his 2nd job after losing his first due to tragedy. McCarthy just finished failing at his 2nd stint and looking for his 3rd.
So no. There’s nothing remotely appropriate comparing the two.