Could Kingsbury replicate his offense with Spencer Rattler?

St. Widge said

It's not hope in a 5th round pick. It's hope in what he did on the field in the last few games and how he improved over his first few starts. I don't think he will be ready next year and Carr gives you the best chance to win next year, but I also think it would be good to move past Carr now, see what we have in Rattler, and then if he isn't him, we can draft a QB in 2026.

Click to expand...

He shows flashes, and I get that, but the odds that a fifth-round guy will turn into a franchise quarterback or even a solid backup are quite low. The pragmatic route is to go with Carr and look for a quarterback in the first round in 2026. Every guy in the NFL has potential, but this fantasy that a mid-round guy will be elite just because he was a top recruit in high school is unrealistic.