I don’t get the argument that Payton and McCarthy resumes are similar, so let’s hire the other guy since we can’t have Payton.
A similar resume for McCarthy does not equate to success for us. Different franchises. Different teams. Different circumstances. You have to look past the numbers. Did he do worse than he should have with the talent he had, in GB, in Dallas? I don’t see McCarthy in the same light as Payton from a coaching impact and a personnel guy.