You are, because you’re looking only at last season’s results and concluding that he’d be a bad head coach.
I’m going off the words of people in the league, not what a poster on a message board thinks. I also know that Daniel Jones and their offense had a strong 2022 with NYG, prompting Brian Daboll to think he should run it from there, which has shown to be a mistake. With that in mind, I’d further argue that getting Kafka out of that talent-poor madhouse would be best for him.
Or you could continue to lazily point at the 2024 results and not allow space for a single other factor.