I think you share the sentiment of the majority of us. It’s not that McCarthy is “bad”, but he has had almost 20 years worth of opportunities with much better situations and largely underachieved.
I would hope that most of us can agree that Rodgers and Dak are better QBs than Carr. I would hope we all agree that Dallas’ young/prime talent on defense is much better than our aging talent on defense.
I just don’t know why we would think he can accomplish more in New Orleans than he did in GB/Dallas, and he’s only won 1 playoff game in his entire tenure as the Cowboys HC. It seems like settling to hire McCarthy.