I'd rather go with Kellen Moore.
I'm not a believer in McCarthy. Don't get me wrong. He's not a bad coach what so ever. But Green Bay was exceptional at finding talent before him, during his tenure, and after him. I didn't feel Dallas get better or worse during his tenure there acquiring talent. The more I think about that, the more I realize he's always came into good situations coaching.
Not once have we seen him build a team from the ground up in two decades. That's really remarkable if you think about it. So can he?
No idea if Moore can either. But the unknown of Moore makes it all exciting and he has proven to do a tremendous job with the Eagles offense more so then McCarthy did playing calling in Dallas. So I think I would rather take the risk on Moore.