Enough With the HC Hand Wringing - McCarthy Is the Best Option for the Saints

How can you say that about Mike and not Moore? Dallas and Philly have a lot of talent. I think Garrett got Dallas to the playoffs, and Lamb is an all-pro WR. Not to mention, we don't know if he's a leader of men. Mike coached up AB and a young Rogers.

I'm not sure what you mean. I thought I made it pretty clear that I don't see any proof that either can do it. It stands to reason that McCarthy did coach up Rodgers. And I know Saints fans love to live inside their blinders, but Brooks wasn't anything at all to brag about from a league perspective and McCarthy brought Brooks with him from Green Bay to NO. And Brooks was bleh. I didn't think he was good then, and I still don't now. And we all know good and well that Rickey and Deuce carried those offenses on their back. Not Brooks carrying the offenses with his arm.