The posts above do a great job of discussing the pros and cons of McCarthy versus Moore. All opinions are valid; but without interviewing the candidates, listening to their plan and gauging their leadership qualities through interviews and gathering intel through league references (other coaches and players who have played for both) it's impossible for fans to really know who is the better fit for this job. Let's hope the Saints do a deep dive on both and make the right pick.
But regardless, I think the Saints are selecting between two good options (as good as any prospects hired in this coaching cycle).