Nobody said to hand him the "franchise" QB job uncontested. People want to give him a shot to see IF he is a franchise QB. Nobody is saying that he is or that we should continue to try to upgrade the QB position if we can.
It’s extremely common to see the cut Carr + don’t draft QB take. That’s worse than taking the Raiders strategy from last year. We have to at least find an affordable FA or draft someone like Dart this year.