You made the biggest point: the high failure rate. Talent does matter unless you're just a bad coach. I think hiring Moore is the easy part; finding him an elite quarterback and rebuilding the roster is going to be the hard part.
I still don’t think the roster is in bad shape from a pure talent standpoint. It’s just that Injuries hit nearly all those “talents” and exposed the lack of a middle class.
It further exposed that Carr isn’t a glue type of player that can hold the bridge together when it collapses.
Think about how terrible the 2014 roster was and on the strength of Drew’s arm we still managed 7 wins. Any other QB/Coach barely scrapes 3-4 wins w/ that depleted group.